CASE FILE · GIVEAWAYS

Comment Picker review: features, pricing and verdict

Recommended

Short version: Our Comment Picker review in brief: it's a free, simple way to draw a fair winner from an Instagram post's comments, which earns it 4.5/5/5. The catch is the free plan's 100-comment, one-winner cap, the ads, and the need for a Business or Creator account. Premium costs $9.99 a month and is normally non-refundable.

What is Comment Picker?

Comment Picker is a web tool that draws a random winner from the comments on a social media post. Its Instagram picker works on posts, Reels and videos, and the same site offers pickers for Facebook, YouTube, TikTok, X, Threads, Bluesky and Reddit.

The site says it has offered an Instagram comment picker since 2017 and claims more than 37,000 brands use it, both the company's own figures. It's also the free pick at the top of our giveaway picker list.

Comment Picker features

Here's what our investigation of the official site turned up. Most of the basics are free, and the rules that bigger giveaways rely on sit behind Premium.

Filters on the free plan

Free users can remove duplicate users, include replies, filter by words, hashtags, date range or like count, exclude hidden comments and their own, limit entries per person and exclude usernames. You can add bonus entries by hand, but these skip every filter.

Premium-only rules

Picking up to 10 winners, filtering by @mentions, choosing a winner by first, last or most-liked comment, and removing past winners all need Premium.

Proof of the draw

Free users can download an image certificate and a results image, and pick an animation such as a wheel of names or a countdown. Premium adds your own logo, title and colours to the results.

Multi-post and multi-platform draws

Premium adds giveaways across several posts. A combined Facebook and Instagram draw is also available, but the free plan stops at 50 comments per platform.

What users say about Comment Picker

On Trustpilot, Comment Picker has a TrustScore of 4.6 from 34 reviews (checked November 20, 2026), with 88% five-star and 9% one-star ratings. That's a small sample for a tool the company says runs over 28,000 Instagram giveaways a month.

The positive reviews mostly praise quick support over Instagram and Facebook messages and how easy the picker is to use. The negative ones raise two problems: the tool not selecting all comments or users, and a charge after a Patreon cancellation that wasn't refunded. The company replied that cancellations must happen before the billing cycle renews.

We found no reviews.io profile for Comment Picker.

How Comment Picker works

Comment Picker runs in your browser, so there's nothing to install. You do have to log in, and the whole draw takes a few steps.

Step 1: Log in

Log in with Instagram, or with Facebook if you're an admin of the Facebook Page connected to your Instagram account. You'll need a Business or Creator account.

Step 2: Choose the post

Select the account and the post, Reel or video. On collab posts, only the original creator can load comments through Instagram login, so collaborators should use Facebook login.

Step 3: Set your rules

Pick your filters and entry rules, then choose how the results and the draw animation should look.

Step 4: Load and draw

Press the button to load the comments, then start the draw. The free plan loads up to 100 comments.

Step 5: Share the result

Download an image certificate, share a results image or video, or create a public results page for entrants.

Who is Comment Picker best for?

Comment Picker suits creators and small businesses who run a small giveaway now and then. Once a post passes 100 comments, or your rules ask entrants to tag a friend, you need Premium at $9.99 a month, so weigh that cost before your giveaway goes live.

A good fit if you

  • Run small giveaways with under 100 comments
  • Have an Instagram Business or Creator account
  • Want a certificate showing the draw was random
  • Also run giveaways on TikTok, YouTube or X

Skip it if you

  • Use a personal Instagram account
  • Need @mention rules without paying
  • Want to pick several winners for free
  • Tend to forget to cancel subscriptions

Why use Comment Picker at all?

The main reason to use a picker at all is trust. A certificate or public results page shows entrants the winner wasn't a friend of yours, and Comment Picker's free plan covers that for small posts.

If you need more than Comment Picker gives you, Woobox, Easypromos, Simpliers and WASK are the other pickers in that same list, each with its own limits and prices. Our Easypromos review covers the option built for brand contests.

Running giveaways to grow? Check afterwards who stayed: a follower tracker shows who unfollowed once the prize was gone. Our Reports+ review looks at one popular iPhone app for this. Giveaways work best alongside regular posting, as our follower growth guide explains.

If you only need Premium for one big giveaway, the pricing page lets you cancel anytime through Patreon. Do it before the renewal date, because renewed months can't be refunded. To send every commenter a link or code by DM instead, see our Elev8or Engage review. Our Inrō review covers a tool with giveaway DM templates.

How we reviewed it

Our Comment Picker review draws on the official Comment Picker website, its Instagram picker page and its Premium pricing page, checked on November 20, 2026, along with user reviews on Trustpilot. We didn't run a giveaway of our own for this review.

Every score on the site follows our scoring approach, so you can see how we reach each score out of 5.

What we liked

Free for small draws

The free plan picks a winner from up to 100 comments, with filters for duplicate users, words, hashtags, dates and likes. That covers a typical small creator giveaway at no cost.

Proof you can share

Even free users get a downloadable certificate and a results image, which gives entrants something to check if anyone doubts the draw.

One account, many platforms

The same site has pickers for Facebook, YouTube, TikTok, X, Threads, Bluesky and Reddit, so you don't need a new tool for each network.

What we didn't like

Free draws stop at 100 comments

The free plan loads at most 100 comments from one post and picks one winner. Anything bigger needs Premium, which lifts the comment cap and allows up to 10 winners.

Tag-a-friend rules cost extra

Filtering by @mentions, the usual rule for tag-a-friend giveaways, is listed as a Premium feature on the pricing page. The Instagram picker page is inconsistent on this point, which doesn't help.

No personal accounts

Personal Instagram accounts aren't supported, so you need a Business or Creator account. Logging in with Facebook also means being an admin of the Facebook Page linked to your Instagram account.

Strict billing

Premium is billed through Patreon and renews automatically without a notification, according to the pricing page. Subscriptions are non-refundable under normal circumstances, and one Trustpilot reviewer reported a charge after cancelling.

Ads and no saved results

The free version shows ads, and results aren't saved to your account unless you pay. Download your certificate before you close the page.

What we liked

  • Pro: Free Instagram comment picker
  • Pro: Premium adds multi-post draws
  • Pro: Pickers for Facebook, TikTok, YouTube and more

What we didn't like

  • Con: Free draws stop at 100 comments
  • Con: Free version shows ads
  • Con: Advanced filters need Premium

Comment Picker pricing

Comment Picker plans
PlanPriceWhat you get
Free$01 post, up to 100 comments, 1 winner, text, date and like filters, certificate, with ads
Premium monthly$9.99/monthUnlimited comments and posts, up to 10 winners, @mention filter, multi-post draws, custom branding, saved results, no ads
Premium yearly$95.91/yearEverything in Premium monthly, billed once a year

The yearly plan works out to just under $8 a month. The page says it saves 20% against 12 monthly payments, which add up to $119.88. Prices are in US dollars, plus any local taxes.

Premium is sold through Patreon. It renews automatically, monthly or yearly, and you can cancel anytime there. The page says subscriptions are non-refundable under normal circumstances, and it doesn't mention a free trial.

Other platforms have their own free limits, such as 30 comments per TikTok video and 25 X (Twitter) replies, all listed on the Premium pricing page.

Prices checked November 20, 2026.

Is Comment Picker safe?

Comment Picker says it loads comments through Meta's official API and that its app was approved after Meta's review. You log in through Instagram or Facebook, and the company says the tool won't post to or change your account. The permission to publish content is only needed if you share results to your Stories or feed.

On data, the Instagram picker page says Comment Picker doesn't store or sell your data, yet results can be saved to your account and shared on a public results page. The page doesn't explain the difference, so assume anything on a results page is public.

The fairness claim, a pseudorandom draw the company says it can't influence, comes from Comment Picker itself. We found no independent audit of it.

Before you connect any third-party tool to Instagram, switch on Instagram's two-factor security.

Comment Picker vs alternatives

Comment Picker compared with alternatives
#ToolOur scorePrice fromBest forReview
1Easypromos4/5First giveaway free; Basic $29/monthLarger or recurring giveaways that need rules and proof of fairness

Comment Picker review: our verdict

Our Comment Picker review comes down to the size of your giveaway. Under 100 comments with simple rules, it's a free, fair and quick way to pick a winner, which is why it scores 4.5/5/5. Beyond that you need Premium, and its auto-renewing, no-refund billing needs care. Case closed: use it free for small draws, pay for one month for a big one, and cancel before it renews. For growth between giveaways, see our growth tool reviews.

Does Platypus recommend Comment Picker?

Recommended

Yes for small, free draws. Check the 100-comment cap and Patreon billing before you pay.

4.5/5

FAQ

Is Comment Picker free?

Yes, for small giveaways. The free plan picks one winner from up to 100 comments on a single Instagram post, and it shows ads. Premium costs $9.99 a month or $95.91 a year and adds unlimited comments, up to 10 winners, @mention filtering and multi-post draws.

Is Comment Picker legit?

Yes. The site says it has offered an Instagram comment picker since 2017, and it loads comments through Meta's official API rather than asking for your password. It holds a 4.6 TrustScore on Trustpilot, but from only 34 reviews, and its fairness claims come from the company itself.

Why won't Comment Picker work with my Instagram account?

Most likely you have a personal account. Comment Picker only works with Instagram Business or Creator accounts. If you log in with Facebook, you must be an admin of the Page linked to the Instagram account, and collaborators on a collab post should use Facebook login.

Can I get a refund for Comment Picker Premium?

Usually not. The pricing page says subscriptions, billed through Patreon, are non-refundable under normal circumstances, and renewed months can't be refunded. Plans renew automatically without a notification, so cancel in Patreon before the renewal date if you only needed one month.

Photo of Kathy Piere

Reviewed by

Kathy Piere

Instagram reviews

I review Instagram growth tools for Platypus Reviews, with a focus on niche accounts like local businesses, hobby pages and small creators. I run every tool on a real account, check the new followers by hand, and write down exactly what happened, good or bad.

See Kathy's reviews